ELF Cream Eyeliner

ELF Cream Eyeliners kind of rock!

I am pretty new to these liners and after the Wet n Wild Mega Eyes Cream Liner I loved so much dried out very soon after opening it (I retract loving it that much now and updated the post), I wanted to try these since I heard so much about them. So far so good!

They come in eleven colors, with three brand spanking new ones I haven’t even seen in stores yet which are: Teal Tease, Golden and Punk Purple.

Initially I bought Plum Purple and Midnight and had been planning on reviewing for awhile. I never got around to it yet, then bought four more colors. So I complied them all into this one post.

ELF Cream Eyeliner 2
Clockwise: Metallic Olive, Coffee, Black, Gunmetal

ELF Cream Eyeliner 3
Plum Purple, Midnight

ELF Cream Eyeliner 4

They do come with a little synthetic angled brush which I don’t love and actually toss. I prefer a totally different type of brush when applying cream liners.

ELF Cream Eyeliner Swatches
Metallic Olive, Coffee, Black, Gunmetal

Metallic Olive is a medium metallic olive color. It’s really nicely opaque and you know me and olive green! 😉

Coffee is a medium brown with slight reddish base. This one wasn’t quite as opaque as I would want, a little patchy.

Black is a nice deep creamy black. It’s not as black perhaps as the Wet n Wild one, but it’s not all dried out after opening it either!

Gunmetal is a really nice silvery grey metallic. Creamy as hell.

ELF Cream Eyeliner Swatches 2
Plum Purple, Midnight

Plum Purple is a deep slightly shimmery plum purple color. Very pretty and looks amazing on blue eyes.

Midnight is a very dark navy blue color.


Well worth the $3.00 price tag! I think these are really great creamy liners and I have had two of them opened for 5-6 weeks now, and they are not at all dried up or hardened. I will definitely be looking out for the three new colors also!

Availability: I found mine at Target

Pricing: $3.00 each

What do you think about these? Any colors you like?


Written by Kelly
Vampy Varnish is dedicated to showing high resolution makeup and nail polish swatches, and providing honest product reviews.